Rhode Island Pre-Election Update

Rhode Island General Assembly: Democrats forecast to unseat three incumbents, but may lose an open seat

Share

In this post, I provide what I expect to be final ratings and analysis for competitive elections for state office in Rhode Island. I previously wrote up every contested race for state office here.

I provide a “PVI” measure for each district, which is relative to the state and represents the median two-party margin in partisan elections for statewide non-federal office across the 2018 and 2022 elections. As a note, I mention “individual contributions” many times below in my writeups. I think it's worth mentioning that RI classifies campaign contributions received from another person's campaign as “individual” contributions, even attributing them to the appropriate candidate in their individual capacity. While I would love to break that out as its own field, I actually don't have a way to do that without checking expenditure data.

I reserve the right to change any ratings until polls close.

Rating Change Summary

I have the following rating changes, four in favor of Democrats and two in favor of Republicans.

District Old Rating 09/27 New Rating 11/03
SD 34 Lean Republican Tilt Democratic
HD 27 Pure Tossup Tilt Republican
HD 42 Pure Tossup Tilt Democratic
HD 44 Likely Democratic Lean Democratic
HD 49 Pure Tossup Tilt Democratic
HD 53 Lean Republican Tilt Republican

Below are tables and maps of my updated State Senate and State House ratings.

State Senate (38 seats, no tiebreaker)
Uncontested R Lean R Tilt D Likely D Safe D Uncontested D
21 (Rogers) 17 (Paolino) 34 (Morgan) 33 (Raptakis) 5 (Bell) 30 D-held seats
23 (de la Cruz) 14 (Lawson)
38 (Gu)
Map showing 30 Uncontested Democratic seats, 3 Safe Democratic (5, 14, 38), 1 Likely Democratic (33), 1 Lean Republican (17), 1 Tilt Democratic flip (34), and 2 Uncontested Republican (21, 23).
My current Rhode Island State Senate ratings.
State House (75 seats)
Uncontested R Safe R Tilt R Tilt D Lean D Likely D Safe D Uncontested D
6 R-held seats 41 (Chippendale) 27 (Serpa) 15 (Paplauskas) 22 (Solomon) 5 (DeSimone) 7 D-held seats 50 D-held seats
53 (Santucci) 39 (Cotter) 44 (Costantino) 23 (Shekarchi)
42 (Fascia) 67 (Knight)
49 (Brien)
The map shows 50 Uncontested Democratic districts, seven Safe Democratic (7, 13, 18, 19, 33, 35, 37), three Likely Democratic (5, 23, 67), two Lean Democratic (22, 44), four Tilt Democratic (15-flip, 39, 42-flip, 49-flip), two Tilt Republican (27-flip, 53), one Safe Republican (41), and six Uncontested Republican (21, 28, 29, 40, 47, 48).
My current Rhode Island State House ratings.

Statewide Offices

Governor

To defeat the frontrunner, Democratic nominee Helena Buonanno Foulkes, independent candidate Ken Block needs to do two things: surpass Republican nominee Aaron Guckian with right-leaning voters, and peel off a number of moderates and independents who typically vote for Democrats. This is a tall order, but Block has been working hard at fulfilling it. Several prominent Republicans in Rhode Island have endorsed Block, including Elaine Pelino, who narrowly lost the primary to Guckian, as well as 2022 gubernatorial nominee Ashley Kalus. CVS also recently was in the news for a major federal settlement over the opioid crisis, which has brought fresh scrutiny to Foulkes's tenure at the company.

Block is running a better campaign than I'd expected. But he's still far behind Foulkes in fundraising. It's worth noting that not a single poll in 2018 had Gina Raimondo winning a majority, and all underestimated her margin, although one (the September UNH poll) was close. I had already decided to keep this race at Safe Democratic, but it didn't hurt when we got a new Ocean State Poll from UNH in the last few days that shows Foulkes opening up a 55%-34% lead, with Guckian still taking 8%. Even before leaners were pushed, Foulkes had 53% in the poll. Block has done a very good job of neutralizing Guckian, but it's not going to be enough.

Lieutenant Governor

A couple polls in early October showed the Republican nominee, John Loughlin II, neck-and-neck with first-term Democratic incumbent Sabina Matos. I do think it'll be a close race, but I don't think Loughlin will actually become the first Republican to win statewide since 2006. The “since 2006” figure actually understates how big of a deal it would be for Loughlin to win, in my opinion. The most recent Republican wins have been for Governor or U.S. Senator. The last time a Republican won one of the four state row offices – Lieutenant Governor, Secretary of State, Attorney General, or General Treasurer – was all the way back in 1992; I observe that they actually won three of the four that year, unseating two Democratic incumbents. The one they didn't win that year was Lieutenant Governor. Want to know the last time a Republican was elected Lieutenant Governor? It was sixty years ago. Yes, 1966, during the Johnson administration.

Loughlin has received a bit of scrutiny over campaign finance mistakes, which has helped Matos neutralize her own past election paperwork scandal. He's been outspent nearly 4:1 in the closing weeks, and Matos has raised a little over twice as much from individual contributions as he has. I'm holding my rating at Likely Democratic. I can't entirely rule out an upset, but Matos is still clearly favored. UNH also polled this race and found Matos leading 53% to 40% before leaners were pushed, and 56% to 41% after pushing leaners.

Other Statewide and Federal Offices

Since my last post, there have been no substantial developments in any of the other statewide or federal races, which all remain safely Democratic.

State Senate

Senate District 14

PVI: D+16

I promised an update here, where Senate President Valarie Lawson (D) faces former Rep. Brian Gary Coogan (I). Coogan is receiving support from a couple notable figures in East Providence politics. Chrissy Rossi, who chairs the East Providence Republican City Committee, included him in a meet and greet that was clearly only for her favored candidates. And Anna Sousa, who represents Ward 2 on the City Council, is his campaign treasurer. (Unsurprisingly, East Providence Democrats are seeking to oust Sousa.)

As of July 1, Lawson had over $300,000 on hand to Coogan's $0. In the period ending Oct. 5, she proceeded to handily outraise him anyway, although Coogan did raise a bit more from individuals. Spending, on the other hand, isn't close. Lawson spent $53,745.90 to Coogan's $4,370.50, a 12:1 edge. In the final reporting period (10/05-10/26), both candidates essentially stopped fundraising, and Lawson spent $15,243.18 to Coogan's $357.93, although Coogan did receive an additional $695 in value from in-kind contributions. There are a few independent expenditures backing Lawson here also.

The race remains Safe Democratic.

Senate District 17

PVI: R+15

Thomas J. Paolino (R-inc.); Nelly Burdette (D); John Douglas Barr, II (I); Jina N. Petrarca (I).

Petrarca, Barr, and Paolino are all conservatives, making Burdette the sole liberal in the race. Given the crowded field, here's a table with the financial data. I have excluded Petrarca's $30,000 contribution to her campaign, which was not a loan, from all categories except the self-funding row.

Period Category Paolino Burdette Barr Petrarca
07/01-10/05 Contribs. $8,954.68 $6,825.00 $0.00 $0.00
Indiv. contribs. $8,954.68 $5,325.00 $0.00 $0.00
Self-fund $0 $0 $2,000 $30,000
In-kind $0.00 $160.65 $0.00 $0.00
Expend. $5,705.12 $8,691.51 $1,495.65 $11,470.96
10/06-10/26 Contribs. $3,498.45 $3,900.00 $0.00 $0.00
Indiv. contribs. $3,498.45 $3,150.00 $0.00 $0.00
Self-fund $0 $0 $9,700 $30,000
In-kind $0.00 $545.61 $0.00 $0.00
Expend. $4,991.11 $3,777.24 $9,724.94 $18,157.38

Individual contributions are competitive between Paolino and Burdette, with Paolino leading. Both independents are entirely self-funded, and although that means I can't directly compare fundraising statistics, self-funded candidates are generally weaker, all other things being equal. Barr's expenditures include signs, a newspaper ad, and mail as well as a campaign website. Petrarca is largely outsourcing her campaign to Checkmate, which is a prominent political consulting group in Rhode Island. Burdette's spending is dominated by mail and palmcards, and Paolino's expenditures are largely classified as “advertising” but are for unspecified purposes.

Looking at endorsements, NEARI, the state's leading educators' union, endorsed Burdette, joining the Working Families Party, which had already backed her. The SEIU Council has done the same. However, the state AFL-CIO, in an incredible lapse of judgment, has endorsed John Douglas Barr II. Barr last won an election in 2000, when I was two years old. Since then, he has run in six general or special elections, losing all of them, and in three contested primaries, winning one. His leading opponent in the one primary was a certain John J. Cullen, who has a even more abysmal electoral record. (Cullen was also Barr's opponent in his first three primaries back in the 1990s.) The third candidate was Louis E. Azar, who went on to become the only person to ever lose a primary or election to Cullen to my knowledge. It doesn't take a genius to realize this will be the ninth election Barr loses in a row. In other words, the Rhode Island AFL-CIO is helping reelect Thomas Paolino. Another bizarre element here is that I am not aware of any union endorsements for Barr in 2020, when he was the only person running against Paolino. Why back him now?

To my surprise, left-wing grassroots group Reclaim RI has gotten involved here, joining the WFP in backing Burdette. While both organizations have strong records of electing their endorsed candidates, Reclaim, which focuses on housing, is significantly more selective about its endorsements. I note that the Reclaim victories I am familiar with thus fare have all come all in primaries, not general elections.

Planned Parenthood Votes! RI and Affordable Rhode Island (SEIU 1199NE) are both running Facebook ads in support of Burdette that seem to have a broad reach. Petrarca is running various ads on the platform with medium reach, and ads from Paolino and the Republican Party show the smallest reach. I did not note any pro-Barr ads on Facebook. There do not appear to be any YouTube ads running here. The RI Values Project (PPVRI/SEIU 1199NE/RICAGV) has spent on pro-Burdette mail, and the Affordable RI expenditure is too large to be fully accounted for by Facebook ads.

Coordination failures among Democrats are a big part of why Paolino has won five terms, and this year may well fit the pattern. If Paolino wins in November with a mere plurality, Pat Crowley and Jina Petrarca will bear much of the blame. That said, Burdette is getting enough backing that I'm not comfortable moving the race to Likely. I'd note that the AFL-CIO's gamble on Barr has a downside, too: if Burdette wins, she certainly won't owe it to the Democratic establishment. Lean Republican.

Senate District 33

PVI: R+24

From 07/01-10/05, Sen. Leonidas Raptakis (D) outraised his challenger, James Pierson (R), 5:1 with individuals and outspent him 37:1. However, in the final three weeks, Pierson finally began spending, and Raptakis barely has a 2:1 spending edge for that period. I had this race at Likely Democratic out of an abundance of caution, and I'm keeping it there, although I honestly think Pierson has a better chance of getting reelected to the Coventry School Committee than he does of ousting Raptakis.

Senate District 34

PVI: R+23

From July 1 to October 5, Democratic nominee Samantha Wilcox outraised Republican incumbent Elaine Morgan with individuals, $7,497 to $5,918, although Morgan raised slightly more overall due to PAC and party contributions. During the same period, Wilcox spent $7,305.72 to Morgan's $2,835.27, about a 2.5:1 edge. The Oct. 6-26 period was a similar story, with Wilcox raising $1,895.00 from individuals to $275.00 for Morgan; Wilcox spent $13,410.55 to Morgan's $5,520.97, and ended with $2,492.41 on hand to $8,545.03 for Morgan. Both candidates' spending is largely on mail, but Wilcox did purchase palmcards for canvassing.

Since the primary, Wilcox, who serves as the Richmond Town Council president, has been endorsed by both the state AFL-CIO and NEARI. This is clearly the most serious challenge Morgan has had since her 2016 rematch with her predecessor, Catherine Cool Rumsey. Morgan is backed by RI Right to Life (RI RtL) and LORIB, as well as the NRA, although I observe that the NRA gave Wilcox a B rating.

Neither candidate seems to be running Facebook or YouTube ads, nor do any outside groups appear to be running ads in this race, and indeed no independent expenditures have been reported that I can tell.

I wouldn't describe Wilcox as a progressive, exactly, but she'd be a breath of fresh air compared to Morgan. Her political approach distinctly resembles that of Rep. Megan Cotter, whose district is wholly contained within SD 34.

Oddly enough, every metric points to Wilcox. I expect a very close race. I'm hesitant to hope here, but the stars may at last be aligning to send Elaine Morgan home. I can't believe I'm doing this, but I am moving SD 34 all the way to Tilt Democratic (flip). Obviously, if I'm wrong I'll regret doing so, but that's not a very compelling reason to avoid predicting what I think will happen, is it?

State House

House District 5

PVI: D+29

Incumbent Anthony deSimone (D) faces a challenge from Brittany Kubicek (“Socialist”). My initial rating was Likely Democratic. In the 07/01-10/05 campaign filing, Kubicek reported raising $5,017 from individuals to deSimone's $0 (really), while deSimone spent an effective $9,657.61 to Kubicek's $6,382.99. In the 10/06-10/26 filing, deSimone raised $2,300 from individuals to Kubicek's $570, and deSimone spent $6,784.53 to an effective $1,525.68 from Kubicek. DeSimone had $52,340.18 on hand on 10/26 to Kubicek's $2,008.60.

Looking at endorsements, Kubicek appears to have obtained exactly zero endorsements outside of RI DSA. This is a break from historical patterns, where insurgent DSA candidates would generally obtain a handful of other endorsements, such as Reclaim, Sunrise, and CARI. Even Run for Something hasn't endorsed her campaign. There are two possible explanations. One is that she applied for endorsements but every organization she sought the endorsement of declined to endorse her. The other is that she didn't apply for any endorsements outside of RI DSA. Neither is a good sign for her chances.

As I've noted many times, Providence DSA had a strong electoral record, although today it has essentially been supplanted in that space by Reclaim. Trying to get elected without a single endorsement outside of DSA is certainly an interesting strategy. Many organizations admittedly ask for a significant time commitment in exchange for allowing the candidate to put their logo on a piece of paper. But there are also organizations like the WFP, Reclaim, and the SEIU, whose endorsements are a major boost to candidates.

Where are those organizations, you ask? The WFP and Reclaim are both sitting the race out, while the SEIU has endorsed deSimone. DeSimone is also benefitting from a $784.20 mailer by the RI Values Project supporting him – yes, that means PPVRI and the RI Coalition Against Gun Violence have also endorsed him. Reside & Thrive, which is funded by the RI Builders Association, spent $2,676.69 on pro-deSimone mail.

Democratic Left, the official publication of national DSA, wrote what is essentially an op-ed about the race. I found it striking that the op-ed claims “DeSimone inherited the seat from his father”. Marcia Ranglin-Vassell, the progressive schoolteacher who defeated John deSimone in the 2016 primary in a major upset and served six years in the seat, might disagree with that characterization. Ranglin-Vassell has endorsed many candidates over the years, and yet she's silent about this race. In fact, the only endorsement, besides that of DSA, that Kubicek has shared during the campaign is that of progressive independent journalist Steve Ahlquist.

Correction: Ranglin-Vassell issued an endorsement of Kubicek on Facebook on Monday, which I had missed. Kubicek does not appear to have posted about the endorsement. H/t Michael Garman.

I don't see any reason to move this race into a more competitive column, and in fact, I will be stunned if Kubicek pulls off the upset. But I haven't quite seen enough from deSimone to move it in the other direction, either. My rating remains Likely Democratic, although it is close to being Safe.

House District 15

PVI: R+25

My original rating here was Tilt Democratic. Incumbent Christopher G. Paplauskas (R) faces former Cranston City Council member Colleen M. Crudele (D) and former Mayor Allan W. Fung (I). As Crudele left office when I was less than a year old, I admit I was not aware of her time on the Council when I wrote my original preview of this race.

For the 07/01-10/05 period, Fung led in individual contributions, raising $21,550 to Paplauskas's $17,325 and Crudele's $11,991.79. Fung also loaned himself $50,000. Paplauskas led in spending with $27,023.66 and received a further $483 of in-kind contributions. Fung was in second, having spent $20,361.62 and received a further $3,030 of in-kind contributions. Crudele spent $10,345.14 and received no in-kind contributions. Moving to 10/06-10/26, Crudele actually raised the most from individuals, at $6,689.10, while Fung and Paplauskas were essentially tied, raising $4,950 and $4,925 respectively. Fung led in spending with an effective $21,130.90, Paplauskas spent $14,958.64, and Crudele spent $8,522.21. As of Oct. 26, Fung had $41,007.48 on hand to $12,377.90 for Paplauskas and $3,563.54 for Crudele.

Crudele has received endorsements from NEARI and the SEIU Council, which is a conspicuously short list for a Democrat. The Current's Nancy Lavin notes that she previously ran in the 2006 primary and further points out that she is the cousin of Rep. Frank Montanaro Jr., who held this seat for many years. Considering that Montanaro Sr. led the RI AFL-CIO for nineteen years, it seems notable that they passed on endorsing Crudele.

Paplauskas, meanwhile, has been endorsed by the NRA and RI RtL, and I am not aware of any endorsements for Fung. As for advertising, the RI Republican Party is running an ad for Paplauskas on Facebook, while Fung has a few spots on YouTube.

After some reflection, I think there's a decent chance many voters perceive Fung's campaign as something of a vanity project or personal grievance (and they'd arguably be right), but he is still likely to draw a meaningful share of the vote due to name recognition. Fung and Paplauskas clearly hate each other, and the more they fight, the better Crudele is positioned. I don't usually advise candidates to stay quiet and avoid attacking their opponents, but when your opponents are doing the dirty work for you, there's little downside to staying “above the fray”. My rating remains Tilt Democratic.

House District 22

PVI: R+12

My original rating here was Lean Democratic. Barbara Quigley (R) faces Zakary J. Pereira (D) to succed Joseph J. Solomon Jr., who unsuccessfully sought higher office. Pereira already won a wide range of union and progressive endorsements in the primary, while Quigley is backed by the NRA, LORIB, and RI RtL.

In the 07/01-10/05 period, Pereira raised $11,192 from individuals and spent $18,428.07, while Quigley raised $3,352.82 from individuals and spent $1,739.79; however, given Pereira's contested primary, this is not an apples-to-apples comparison. In the 10/06-10/26 filing, Pereira raised $1,850 from individuals to Quigley's $785, but Quigley outspent Pereira, $4,352.52 to $5,506.95. Quigley ended the period with just $696.08 on hand, while Pereira had $5,811.41.

Pereira is benefitting from the RI Values Project mailer ($587.18), the only IE that I'm aware of here. There's a nonzero chance Quigley pulls this off, but a nonzero chance of an upset doesn't mean it's a tossup. To be frank, I also think the LORIB endorsement is a negative, though I'm not yet sure whether the group is itself unpopular or if its endorsement is merely correlated with poor candidate quality. The race remains Lean Democratic.

House District 23

PVI: R+9

My original rating here was Likely Democratic. Dana James Traversie (R) faces Warwick City Council member William Muto (D) to succeed former Speaker K. Joseph Shekarchi. Muto has led comfortably in individual fundraising and spending, and he even matched Traversie's individual fundraising in the 28BE report despite Traversie's filing covering an additional two months. Traversie is backed by LORIB, the NRA, and RI RtL. Muto has maintained backing from progressive organizations and received an endorsement from NEARI, but the AFL-CIO passed on the race. Reside & Thrive spent $2,106.54 on a pro-Muto mailer. An R+9 PVI is fairly blue-leaning and means I'd need a lot of evidence that Traversie is favored to counterbalance the district partisanship. But all signs point to Muto holding the seat, and I'm holding my rating at Likely Democratic.

House District 27

PVI: R+15

My original rating here was Pure Tossup. Attorney Lawrence P. Almagno [the G is not silent] Jr. (R) faces West Warwick School Committee member Angela S. Coburn (D) for this open seat, with heterodox Rep. Patricia Serpa (D) retiring after many years. Serpa has endorsed Coburn, as have at least for statewide unions (NEARI, UNAP, the AFL-CIO, and the IBPO), while Almagno's only endorsement that I track comes from LORIB. Coburn also appears to have backing from local public safety unions. Interestingly, it seems neither candidate responded to the NRA's survey, and Almagno was merely “recommended” by Right to Life, suggesting he may have ignored them as well. I'm not sure if this is an attempt to present himself as moderate or just poor organization. (Serpa, the incumbent, is pro-life but supports gun control measures.) Coburn has also been endorsed by Sen. John Burke, who represents the West Warwick part of the district, and Rep. Earl Reed III, both of whom are conservative Democrats.

Looking at candidate finances, from 07/01 to 10/05, Coburn raised $10,085 from individuals versus $5,855.42 for Almagno, and Coburn had a narrow spending edge, $7,520.72 to $7,104.43, but Almagno also received $752.48 in value from in-kind contributions. In the 10/06-10/26 period, Coburn raised $6,000 from individuals to Almagno's $2,293.96. Almagno has outspent Coburn 100:1 in the final stretch ($11,825.89 to $100), and he ended with only $1,211.67 on hand to Coburn's $14,859.28.

Looking at the expenditures in more detail, Almagno heavily focuses on voter contact and is making direct payments to vendors, while Coburn's only major expenses were a $3,621.25 payment to the consultants at Checkmate and a $2,918.02 payment for a fundraiser. For what it's worth, Almagno paid the same venue $349 for a fundraiser.

Almagno has spent modestly on Facebook ads, which have achieved substantial reach, while Coburn, who does have a Facebook page (just no website) is silent. Most of Almagno's ads are positive, but he also has a negative spot that depicts Coburn as a likely rubber stamp for Speaker Blazejewski. Almagno frequently posts video content and appears to be significantly more active in general. He emphasizes affordability, although his proposed solutions are largely doctrinaire conservative proposals. However, he does support reversing Gov. Raimondo's cuts to pensions. I did find it odd that multiple Facebook posts by Almagno say “our district was decided by just a few neighbors” in 2024, seeing as Serpa won by 20% (over 1500 votes). Perhaps he's referring to Trump's 3% margin (223 votes)?

This is a tricky one. Coburn has won several endorsements and Almagno's only endorsement is probably a negative. But all the other factors point to Almagno. This would be one of the bluer districts represented by a Republican if he wins, but Sen. Paolino and Rep. Hopkins both represent similar or bluer districts. As it happens, the Democratic nominee in the 2024 race Hopkins won had also served multiple terms in local elected office, and while LORIB didn't exist at the time, it has endorsed her this year. I have a pretty low degree of confidence here, but I'm tilting this to Almagno, giving Republicans their sole expected pickup. Tilt Republican (flip).

House District 37

PVI: R+5

I said I'd keep an eye on this one, and I have. Spending here is close, but the district partisanship is such that Christopher Stanton (R) has an extremely uphill battle to unseat longtime Rep. Samuel Azzinaro (D). Azzinaro is backed by RI RtL, the NRA, NEARI, and the AFL-CIO, while LORIB is backing Stanton. Something I learned in the primary this year: when fundraising is the only sign a race might be competitive and a LORIB candidate is involved, I shouldn't weight fundraising as heavily. (By contrast, in HD 27 above, there are also other factors pointing to Almagno.) My rating here remains Safe Democratic.

House District 39

PVI: R+23

Megan Cotter (D), a progressive who is seeking a third term, represents one of the reddest districts held by a Democrat; she faces Hopkinton Town Council member Jasmin Roy (R). Cotter led handily in fundraising from 07/01 to 10/05, raising $16,089.19 from individuals to Roy's $2,198.84, with both candidates also raising thousands from PACs. During that period, Cotter spent $19,403.05 to Roy's $7,103. In the 10/06-10/26 period, fundraising was minimal for both, and Roy spent $6,934.92 to an effective $5,133.82 from Cotter, with virtually all of Cotter's spending there being digital ads, even though she…isn't running Facebook or YouTube ads (neither is Roy). Both candidates have spent substantially on mail.

Cotter is endorsed by PPVRI, several unions, CARI, and Reclaim RI, while Roy's only endorsement I track is from LORIB. Right to Life merely “recommended” Roy, and the NRA, which issued a C rating to Cotter, indicates Roy did not respond to their survey. I can't exactly write this off as an attempt at moderation, unlike Almagno above; Roy's website makes clear she is opposed to any sort of gun control whatsoever.

Affordable RI, the SEIU 1199NE front group, has spent $19,007.64 to back Cotter; the Facebook ad with the most reach emphasizes ALPR limits, but other ads mention data centers and Cotter's general platform. The Republican Party ran a small Facebook ad backing Roy.

Cotter's campaign has been less active than I'd like in the home stretch, but Roy isn't really doing anything to attract the voters who've rejected Justin Price in the last two elections. (It probably doesn't help that Price is on the ballot in Richmond.) And the spending from Affordable RI should help make up the difference. I'm holding this at Tilt Democratic.

House District 42

PVI: R+22

There are few new endorsements to report here. Edward Stravato (D) has been endorsed by the SEIU Council and basically no one else, while Rep. Richard Fascia (R) has, as expected, received the backing of the NRA and Right to Life. Curiously, it appears Stravato did not respond to the NRA's questionnaire. This would be unremarkable if he were a progressive, but all signs, including his own stated views, point to him being a classic right-wing Johnston Democrat. LORIB is backing Fascia, and he has received union endorsements of his own, including RIFTHP, RI SAFF, and several police/correctional unions.

The Republican Party is running a small Facebook ad buy for Fascia, while no Facebook ads mention Stravato (indeed, he has a minimal social media presence), and there are no YouTube/Google ads. Looking at campaign finances, from 07/01 to 10/05 Fascia raised $10,633.25 from individuals to only $2,863 for Stravato, who is largely self-funded. Stravato spent $22,946.59 to Fascia's $9,750.21 in the same period. In the 10/06-10/26 filing, Stravato raised $13,275 from individuals to Fascia's $52.06 (not a typo), giving Stravato an edge in that metric since 07/01 overall; Stravato continued to outspend Fascia, $18,038.26 to $7,226.11. Stravato ended with $21,877.85 on hand, while Fascia had $10,257.55 in the bank. I was surprised to find that Stravato is mostly making direct payments to vendors rather than operating through consultants; the same is true for Fascia, except for the part about me being surprised. Stravato had several expenses related to volunteer canvassing, something I did not spot in Fascia's filings.

I am tilting this race toward Stravato; unlike the other districts I previously had as pure tossups, I made this decision a couple weeks ago, and I still feel comfortable with it. Tilt Democratic (flip).

House District 44

PVI: R+23

My original rating here was Likely Democratic. Conservative incumbent Gregory Costantino (D) faces small business owner Joseph Hosey (R). Looking at the finances, Hosey raised $3,074.83 from individuals (and a total of $3,924.83) from 07/01-10/05. Costantino spent $8,042.51, while Hosey spent $4,684.34, and Hosey also received $282.56 of in-kind contributions. Moving to the 10/06-10/26 filing, neither candidate raised any money, and Hosey took the lead in spending, with $4,104.57 to Costantino's $1,476. Hosey received a further $1,034.28 in in-kind value during this period. (It appears Costantino does not accept campaign contributions.) Neither candidate's expenditures demonstrate particular strategic acumen, but it does appear both have spent on mail, and Hosey also purchased palmcards. (The in-kind contributions to Hosey are also mail, from the Smithfield Republican Town Committee.)

There is a relative paucity of endorsements here, with progressive issue groups understandably staying out and unions notably also avoiding the race. Three organizations I track have endorsed Costantino: RI RtL, the NRA, and LORIB. Of course, these are all conservative groups. The silence from unions is deafening. Costantino has been endorsed by Lincoln Town Administrator Philip Gould, who is an independent.

Costantino managed to get some earned media recently by, uh, endorsing Paul Santucci over in HD 53 (h/t Ian Donnis), which he did by mailing a letter to HD 53 voters, per a campaign filing. He said he is endorsing Santucci because “this election is too important to remain silent” and criticized progressives in Providence. It's unclear what any of that has to do with Suzy Alba or Paul Santucci. As I said over on Twitter, Costantino is endorsing Santucci because Costantino is a conservative who wants Santucci to win the election; it has nothing to do with Providence.

Costantino has also come out against Question 17 in Smithfield, which would take over the town's two independently run public libraries. I think that's the closest I've seen him come to a progressive stance on any issue, uh, ever, and it's the first time I can recall agreeing with him on anything.

Most metrics are quieter here than I'd like. I don't see a reason to expect a Costantino loss, but there's clearly not enough data to support me moving this race into the Safe column, either. Given the district's underlying partisanship and the uncertainty, I am moving the race to Lean Democratic.

House District 49

PVI: D+1

My original rating here was Pure Tossup. Veronicka Vega (D) is attempting to oust far-right incumbent Jon D. Brien (I). Vega seems to be a progressive and is certainly at least a mainstream liberal. Several industry lobby PACs and unions, including the correctional unions, have donated to Brien's campaign, and he is endorsed by Right to Life (the NRA does not seem to be aware of his candidacy). NEARI is sitting the race out, as is the overall SEIU Council, but SEIU 1199NE is quietly backing Brien, while the AFL-CIO and BCTC at least posted the endorsement themselves. Vega does has organizational backing from two organizations that can provide a major boost to their endorsed candidates: the Working Families Party and Reclaim RI.

When I covered Brien's electoral history in my main post, I missed that he ran for Mayor of Woonsocket in 2020 against then-incumbent Lisa Baldelli-Hunt, who is a Democrat (Woonsocket's elections are nonpartisan). Brien lost that race by 16.4%. Brien wasn't the first sitting city council member to run against Baldelli-Hunt and get obliterated, but he was the last. Well, the last to date, anyway. I guess we'll see what happens with her City Council bid.

Several current representatives have donated to each candidate, although the contribution amounts tend to be much larger for Brien, perhaps because the donors all gave from their campaign accounts. He has also received small donations from former Speakers Murphy and Mattiello. Both candidates have received donations from Woonsocket Mayor Chris Beauchamp, who is a Democrat, while City Council President Dan Gendron, a conservative who is running against Beauchamp, has donated only to Brien.

Looking at fundraising, in the 28BE report (07/01-10/05), Brien raised $6,300 from “individuals” to $1,878 for Vega. However, if contributions from the campaign accounts of current state representatives are removed, those figures become $2,300 and $1,778 respectively. Brien led substantially in spending, with $15,082.02 in expenditures to just $3,965.13 by Vega, although Vega also received $323.65 in in-kind contributions. Both candidates spent less than $1.2K in the first half of the year. Moving to the 10/06-10/26 filing, Brien raised $4,350 from individuals to $2,489 for Vega and outspent her $10,330.06 to $2,922.11. Brien had $11,835.51 left on hand, while Vega had $2,554.21 left.

Reside & Thrive has spent $2,337.82 on a pro-Brien mailer, while Affordable RI, which is backing Vega, has spent $7,952.35 on whatever it is they do, including Facebook ads emphasizing Vega's support for limits on data centers and Flock cameras. The Values Project conspicuously passed here, presumably because of the SEIU's neutrality here; I have to wonder if the SEIU received pressure from the labor establishment to stay out. However, PPVRI is spending directly on Facebook ads saying “the choice could not be clearer” (they're not wrong). There are no pro-Brien Facebook ads and no YouTube ads at all. The WFP and Reclaim have not reported any expenditures, although Reclaim's utility is largely derived from its enthusiastic volunteers anyway.

Despite setbacks for Vega with unions, the race remains competitive. This is another tough one, especially as the district swung sharply to the right in the 2024 presidential race (its federal PVI is now R+5). Downballot races tend to lag, but part of that lag is that downballot candidates are sometimes out of step with their party's national platform. That's not really the case here. Vega trails badly in spending and fundraising, but not so badly that I can write her off.

Brien is something of a unique figure in the General Assembly. There are several representatives who share his views, but the only one as caustic and openly hateful as Brien that I can think of is James McLaughlin – who, of course, has lost the last three elections to a normal Democrat, including two primaries as well as the 2024 general election, where he ran as an independent. (McLaughlin represented HD 57, which is D+7.) The other obvious comparison is Donald Trump, who in spite of flipping Woonsocket in 2024 still lost HD 49 by 4.6%. Trump got 42% of the vote in Rhode Island, but UNH found his current approval rating to be just 29%, with 69% disapproving. Brien would be in good (bad?) company if he returned to the Woonsocket City Council, though.

I think this is basically a genuine coin toss, but I'm forcing myself to pick. Tilt Democratic (flip).

House District 53

PVI: R+20

My initial rating here was Lean Republican. Incumbent Paul Santucci (R) faces former Smithfield Town Council President Suzanne “Suzy” Alba. Alba has received a number of endorsements, including three tracked unions (AFL-CIO, NEARI, SEIU Council), PPVRI, and CARI. Right to Life and the NRA are both backing Santucci.

Looking at the 07/01-10/05 financial reports, Alba raised $11,985 from individuals to Santucci's $600 (really), but Santucci spent $5,694.60 to her $2,115.49. From 10/06 to 10/26, Alba raised $5,500 to Santucci's $150 from individuals and spent $11,605.69, while Santucci spent $1,843.68 and had the Smithfield Republican Town Committee pay another $1,034.38 for a mailer. That puts Alba in the lead overall in both fundraising (by a long shot) and spending (more narrowly).

The RI Values Project has spent $455.08 on a pro-Alba mailer, and Alba herself is also spending on mail. As discussed in the HD 44 section, in an unusual move, neighboring Rep. Gregory Costantino spent $2,686.80 to mail voters a letter endorsing Santucci.

I still think Santucci is favored, but even considering his past performances, Lean R may have been a bit aggressive, given that Alba is competitive by all metrics. This race moves to Tilt Republican.

House District 59

PVI: D+47

With Jean Philippe Barros withdrawing for the second cycle in a row, this race is now Uncontested Democratic. There's really nothing more to say. Congratulations to progressive Jennifer Stewart on another term.

House District 67

PVI: D+9

I had thought this race might be competitive. Nicole Jellinek (D) is clearly in the driver's seat in this open race against conservative Warren Town Council President Joseph DePasquale (I). No organizations I track at the state level have endorsed DePasquale, although he did report a check from Teamsters Local 251, which is not a tracked organization. Jellinek has several union endorsements, including the AFL-CIO and both statewide teachers' unions, and is also endorsed by the major progressive and liberal issue groups I track. Looking at current Warren elected officials, Louis Rego, a Democrat who provided the decisive vote for DePasquale's housing resolution, has donated to DePasquale, while Keri Cronin (D) and Nichola Piper (NP) have donated to Jellinek. The remaining two school board members and two councilmembers did not appear to have contributed to either candidate when I checked.

As for campaign activity, in the period from July 1 to October 5, Jellinek raised $9,899 from individuals and $11,849 in total, while DePasquale raised $6,745 from individuals and $11,745 in total, including a $4,000 loan from himself. Jellinek spent $5,790.30 to DePasquale's $2,837.10. Jellinek also reported $384 in in-kind contributions, while DePasquale reported $1,036.46 in the same. Jellinek had a contested primary, so this isn't really an apples-to-apples comparison. DePasquale filed his report thirteen days late, which I thought was noteworthy, as he appears not to have a previous record of violations during his long tenure in office.

From 10/06 to 10/26, Jellinek raised $1,361 to DePasquale's $50, both entirely from individuals. Spending was virtually dead even, with Jellinek spending $1,527.32 and DePasquale spending $1,557.93. I thought it was telling, though, that on the last day of this period, DePasquale repaid the entire $4,000 debt his campaign owed him. That isn't generally something thing you do a week before the election when you think you're in a close race.

The RI Values Project spent $1,379.14 on a pro-Jellinek mailer, the only independent expenditure here that I know of. The only social media ads I found were a pair of small Facebook ads from the Barrington Democratic Town Committee, supporting Jellinek.

I am holding the race at Likely Democratic.


You can subscribe here or drop me a one-time tip here. Thanks for reading. —Eli

Edits: Updated to note Ranglin-Vassell's late endorsement of Kubicek in HD 5, 11/03, 7:52 a.m. EST.

Corrections and feedback can be sent to eli@elium2.com.